How to Find Storytelling Inspiration (Without Waiting for It to Strike)

​

There’s a myth about storytelling that needs to be debunked: that great ideas just appear out of nowhere. That inspiration is something you wait for—like a lightbulb moment that strikes at random.

But here’s the truth: the best storytellers don’t wait for inspiration. They collect it.

I find story inspiration everywhere—mostly when I’m listening to other people. I keep running lists of quotes, things that inspire me, and moments that make me feel something in my notes app. When I need a story, I don’t start from scratch—I go back to my collection.

Even the most successful storytellers use this strategy. Take Aaron Sorkin, the screenwriter behind The West Wing and The Social Network. He’s known for keeping files full of dialogue snippets, observations, and real-life conversations. When it’s time to write, he doesn’t stare at a blank page—he pulls from a well of ideas he’s already gathered.

And there’s a scientific reason why this works.

The Science of Collecting Inspiration

Studies show that the brain connects ideas more effectively when it has more information to pull from.

1. Research published in Harvard Business Review found that the most innovative thinkers actively collect ideas over time rather than relying on sudden bursts of creativity. They don’t just wait for a great idea—they create a system for gathering insights, observations, and concepts that they can later connect in unexpected ways.
2. A study from The Journal of Creative Behavior found that people who expose themselves to a variety of ideas, experiences, and perspectives generate more creative solutions than those who rely on a single source of inspiration.

In short: the more input you have, the easier it is to output great stories.

So if you want to tell better stories, you need to start collecting.

How to Build Your Own Inspiration System

Here’s a simple process to make sure you never run out of storytelling ideas:

1. Listen More Than You Talk

The best stories are happening around you every day—you just have to pay attention.

1. Observe how people talk, how they describe experiences, how they react to situations.
2. Pay attention to emotional moments—when people laugh, get frustrated, or light up while telling a story.
3. Ask more questions. People’s real-life stories are often better than anything you could invent.

2. Keep a Running List of Story Ideas

The worst time to come up with an idea is when you need one. Instead, create an ongoing list of interesting thoughts, phrases, or moments.

1. Use the Notes app on your phone.
2. Keep a physical notebook.
3. Try voice memos if you process ideas better by speaking them out loud.

I have a long-running list of quotes, observations, and things that spark my interest. When it’s time to tell a story, I pull from that instead of trying to think of something on the spot.

3. Capture Moments That Make You Feel Something

The best stories evoke emotion. If something makes you laugh, cry, or rethink your perspective, it’s worth saving.

1. What’s a conversation that stuck with you?
2. What’s a moment in a movie, book, or speech that made you feel something?
3. What’s a small detail that made a story more powerful?

When something moves you, there’s a good chance it will move your audience too.

Turning Inspiration Into Great Stories

Once you’ve built a system for collecting inspiration, the next step is turning those ideas into compelling stories.

Here’s how:

Find the central theme. What’s the main idea connecting all your observations?

Build tension. What problem, challenge, or transformation does the story highlight?

Make it personal. The most memorable stories feel specific and real.

​

Your Challenge: Start Collecting Today

If you want to be a better storyteller, don’t wait for inspiration—collect it.

1. Start a notes file on your phone today. Write down one interesting thing you notice.
2. Listen more actively. Pay attention to the way people tell stories.
3. Save anything that makes you feel something. If it resonates with you, it will resonate with others.

The best stories don’t come from a blank page—they come from a lifetime of listening, noticing, and collecting.

And if you want help turning your ideas into a compelling narrative? Book a free story coaching session with Scout Stories today.

I'm Erin Peterson, part of the team at Scout Stories. Think of us like a therapist, but for stories.

We listen and get the details out.

Provide perspective.

But most importantly, we teach you to create connections, build relationships that attract the right kind of attention.

Want to learn more? https://scoutstorytellers.com/​