Want to Be Authentic? Don’t Say It.


Why “Showing” Beats “Telling” in Storytelling

You don’t have to say it’s vulnerable. You just have to make us feel it.

“I’m showing up vulnerably today.”
How does that land with you?

Now try this:
“I hit ‘publish’ even though my hands were shaking.”

Same emotion. Very different impact.

One tells you how to feel.
The other shows you what it felt like.

And in storytelling, that difference is everything.

Why It Matters

In a world where we scroll past a thousand posts a day, audiences can spot inauthenticity instantly. You don’t need a neon sign that says, “This is inspiring!” or “This is real!”—you need a moment that earns it.

Storytelling isn’t about labeling your emotions.
It’s about revealing them.

And the research backs it up. A 2015 study from neuroscientist Paul Zak found that emotionally rich stories activate multiple parts of the brain—including the sensory and motor cortices—meaning we don’t just understand stories. We experience them. (source)

So if you want to connect? Show us the moment. Don’t just tell us the label.

Try These Three “Show, Don’t Tell” Moves

1. Start with a Moment

Instead of leading with, “I was nervous,” lead with what happened.

“I rewrote this email 12 times before I hit send.”
It’s not about the feeling—it’s about the action that reveals it.

2. Use Dialogue

Real quotes make your story feel real. They bring us into the scene.

What did someone say to you? What did you say to yourself?

“You don’t have to do it perfectly,” she whispered. “You just have to do it.”

That one line gives us more emotion than any adjective ever could.

3. Let the Details Do the Work

Paint the picture. Small, specific details create big emotional resonance.

Instead of, “I was proud,” try:

“I stood at the edge of the stage, clutching the mic, still wearing the shoes I swore I wouldn’t trip in.”

It’s those quiet choices—the ones rooted in real life—that make stories feel universal.

Remember This?

Think about Good Will Hunting.
Robin Williams doesn’t look Matt Damon in the eye and say, “I care about you.”
He just says, “It’s not your fault.”
Again and again.
That restraint? That repetition?
It shows us everything we need to know.

The Bottom Line

If you want people to feel something—don’t explain it. Show them the moment you lived it.

At Scout Stories, that’s what we help clients do every day. Whether you’re crafting a brand video, rewriting your about page, or figuring out how to speak from the stage without sounding like a robot—we help you turn “telling” into truth.

Want to make your brand feel more human?
Let’s work together.


Don’t just say you’re authentic.
Show us the scene that proves it.

SCOUT YOUR STORY

Get weekly, actionable storytelling hacks to help you captivate, sharpen, and make a lasting impact—whether in business, branding, or everyday conversations.

Read more from SCOUT YOUR STORY
Strange, but true: place is a character

How to Use Place as a Character Season 1 Lights GIF by Stranger Things Because strong stories don’t just take place. They live there. Quick—what do you remember about Stranger Things? Sure, the kids. The Demogorgon. The synth-heavy soundtrack. But also?That flickering light in Joyce’s living room. The cold, colorless tunnels of the Upside Down. The flickering neon of Starcourt Mall. Place wasn’t just a backdrop. It was the mood. The tension. The vibe. And that’s what great storytelling...

Steal Tricks from Stand Up

What Storytelling Can Learn from Stand-Up Comedy Stand Up Comedy GIF by Modern Love Because great delivery isn’t just for punchlines. If you want to understand audience dynamics—watch a stand-up comic work a room. At Scout, we study all kinds of communicators. And honestly? Some of the best storytelling lessons don’t come from speakers, marketers, or TED Talk pros. They come from comics. Not just because they’re funny (though that never hurts). But because great comedians know how to hold...

Don't Bury the Lede

Don’t Bury the Lede: How to Hook Your Audience Instantly digging triple h GIF by WWE You’ve got 8 seconds. Sometimes less. That’s all the time you get before someone decides to keep watching, reading, or scrolling. According to Microsoft’s Consumer Insights Report, the average attention span is now just 8.25 seconds. (source) So what happens in those first 8 seconds? They either lean in—or leave. The opening line of your story, post, pitch, or video isn’t just a starting point. It’s your only...